DEEARCHIVEDundee FC History
League · Premier League

Dundee0–0Livingston

18 Sep 2004Saturday, 18 September 2004 · 3pmDens ParkAttendance: 4,387

Lineups

Livingston

Livingston · Starting XI

  • 1Roddy McKenzie
  • 4Oscar Rubio
  • 5Alan Kernaghan
  • 6Emanuel Dorado
  • 2David McNamee
  • 12Craig Easton
  • 17Stuart Love
  • 10Burton O'Brien
  • 3Goran Stanic
  • 16Derek Lilley
  • 8Colin McMenamin

Livingston · Substitutes

  • 18Colin Meldrum
  • 19William Snowdon
  • 11Jason Dair
  • 14Scott McLaughlin
  • 15Richard Brittain
  • 9Jim Hamilton
  • 24Marc Libbra

Livingston · Substitutions

  • Not recorded

Livingston · Manager

  • Allan Preston

Livingston · Cautions

  • Goran Stanic15′
  • David McNamee75′
  • David McNamee90′

Livingston · Red cards

  • David McNamee90′

Match report

A day of poor passing in a stiff breeze wasn't the kind of fare to dish up when a star returned to support his former club, and how we could have done with the skills of one Claudio Paul Caniggia to add some excitement to an encounter that singularly failed to lift the soul. Caniggia's appearance on the Dens turf to make the half time draw was the only time that the support got off their seats and made some noise until the injury time sending off of Steve Lovell and Livi's David McNamee. Managers never quite come out and…Read moreRead less
A day of poor passing in a stiff breeze wasn't the kind of fare to dish up when a star returned to support his former club, and how we could have done with the skills of one Claudio Paul Caniggia to add some excitement to an encounter that singularly failed to lift the soul.

Caniggia's appearance on the Dens turf to make the half time draw was the only time that the support got off their seats and made some noise until the injury time sending off of Steve Lovell and Livi's David McNamee.

Managers never quite come out and say that a match has been shocking, but both Jim Duffy and Allan Preston struggled to say anything good about the game.

Duffy said, "It wasn't the best of games, we had two teams fighting very hard, but too often we hit a long ball instead of passing. A few weeks ago at Hibs we criticised the game for poor defending, but we could've done with some bad defending today. The best players on show were the centre-backs and the full-backs, so that's probably why it ended up goalless."

On the sending off Duffy revealed that Steve Lovell had said sorry for getting involved.

"The sending off was technically correct, but it was just two players involved in a bit of a tussle. I would have liked the referee to have shown more common- sense because there was only seconds left. He could have just said 'Look, it's time up' and forgotten about it, but he didn't and I suppose he was only following the rules. Steve has apologised to the rest of the lads and he knows he gets caught up in things too much sometimes, so I'm not going to be too harsh on him."

Jonay Hernandez missed out with a back problem and Steven Robb was drafted in at left back, but Dundee were otherwise along the same lines as the one on duty at Parkhead. Former Dens favourite Jim Hamilton had to make do with a seat on the bench as Livi tried to end a sequence which had seen them fail to win on their previous seven trips to Dens.

The early stages were scrappy and it was past the quarter hour mark before Dundee's first fluent moment carved out an opportunity. Sutton held the ball up well and fed the overlapping Macdonald who's cross was headed narrowly over by Lovell. Just a minute later Livi had an even better chance and should really have been ahead, Burton O'Brien found himself with space to steady, but steered his shot from the edge of the box onto the base of the post, with Soutar grateful to gather the rebound. On twenty-five minutes, Barry Smith broke up an attack with some tenacious work and lain Anderson sent Steve Lovell racing in on goal from the left, only to be denied by keeper McKenzie's outstretched leg. Right on the break, Dundee had another opportunity as Sutton raced onto Robb's chip and headed narrowly wide of the target.

There was little improvement in the early stages of the second half and Jim Duffy introduced Mark Fotheringham for Barrett in 64 minutes, whilst just seconds earlier Steve Lovell had been booked for persistent fouling and that would prove costly later on. Within seconds of Fozzy's arrival, McKenzie did well again to block Calum Macdonald's close range angled effort following Anderson's free kick.

There was little to stir the supporters, but with eight minutes left Livingston could well have snatched all three points. Lilley's downward header from five-yards beat Soutar, but Bobby Mann popped up on the line to head clear. Duffy brought on Larsen for Brady and the Norwegian showed some nice touches in his short spell on the park, but not enough to grab the full spoils for Dundee.

With the game into injury time, Dundee broke and Steve Lovell appeared to I have space to run in on goal until McNamee tugged him back by the shirt collar, the striker reacted and a mild tussle ensued, Referee Dallas raced across and whipped out his notebook, it could only have one outcome for the two players who had already been booked, a second yellow each and they were taking the long walk down the track for a 'not so' early bath. Allan Preston rightly pointed out that neither club could afford to lose an important player, but a daft moment seconds from time means that their already threadbare squads will be further weakened for their next SPL outing.

Dundee Matchday Programme

Match programme cover